Jesus' Birth Narrative contradictions in the Bible - Godless Engineer

Published: 08 Oct 2018  ·  Uploaded: 19 Nov 2018 Watch on
2297 views  ·  32 mins ago 13:11

Video Description (from Youtube)
What's Up Heathens! Today we are looking at Jesus' Birth Narrative biblical contradiction and explaining why it actually is a problem. General Han Solo tries to explain why there isn't a contradiction but he utterly fails.

So, his solution was to move Herod's death to 1 BC. He also moves Jesus's birth to 3 BC based on Luke’s account, even though that’s inconsistent with Luke’s account. This means that Quirinius’s census of Iudea would now also be in 3 BC. This explanation has a lot of problems and most of them stem from pulling them out of his butt.

The reason he gives for moving Herod's death up is based on when Josephus saw an eclipse. Seriously?!? Never mind that Josephus was writing about these events decades later and wasn't actually present at the time of the eclipse but somehow knew that one occurred when Herod died. Eclipses aren’t globally visible. If you see one in New York, Australians won’t see it. That doesn’t mean that it didn’t happen. After 4 BC, the next lunar eclipse, by Han’s random assertion, would be in 1 BC, so this is when he says Herod would have had to have died. This is a faulty assumption for a few reasons. First, the 4BC eclipse was full (as documented by astronomical formulas), people were well aware it happened and it was recorded by Josephus. Han also claims to have coins that signify that date Herod was alive in 1 BC but I’ve not been able to find any such coins.

After Herod dies, his son Herod Archelaus takes over the region his father ruled and had to travel to Rome in order to get the territory inheritance sorted out with Augustus Caesar. Archelaus’s brother, Antipas was also making a claim for Judea so they needed an official decision from Augustus. While there, Gaius, Augustus’s adopted son, was recorded by Josephus, as being in the meeting with Archelaus and Antipas. This simply could not have happened in 1 BC because by 2 BC Gaius had already departed Rome and was documented to have spent the next several years traveling.

Han totally neglects the fact that Herod's son, Herod Archelaus, takes over after Herod dies but by moving all of these dates, he places Quirinius as governing the area while Herod is still alive (based on his explanation that Herod didn’t die until 1 BC). Historical documents show that Archelaus ruled for 10 years (4 BC to 6AD) and was thrown out of power by Augustus Caesar who then appointed Quirinius legate of Iudea in 6 AD. Furthermore, it’s difficult to argue that Quirinius was ruling Iudea in 3 BC when history records him as accompanying Gaius Caesar on his travels in the East as his tutor.

Video Links:
Gen Han Solo:


Subscribe to this channel:
Become a Patron:

Intro by "Gonna Go For it":

FOLLOW me on Twitter:
LIKE on Facebook:
FOLLOW on Instagram:
FOLLOW on Twitch:

Shared on: 19 Nov 2018

DISCLAIMER All videos are for educational purposes only. The video is hosted on Youtube. The Video Title is derived from the original Youtube video title, video content, dialogue, speech or general content theme. The Video Title does not represent the views of any individual, speaker, organisation or business. Video Titles are further edited and optimized for SEO, keyword density, information and internal/external search. If you spot any mistake, omission or to report abuse kindly contact us.

16   Videos with 'Godless engineer'
Video: 7:10
4485 views · 39 mins ago | 6 years ago
1 of 16   
Video: 9:29
4202 views · 55 mins ago | 6 years ago
2 of 16   
Video: 21:47
5604 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
3 of 16   
Video: 23:55
3981 views · 34 mins ago | 6 years ago
4 of 16   
Video: 13:11
2298 views · 0 secs ago | 6 years ago
5 of 16   
Video: 14:28
3490 views · 33 mins ago | 6 years ago
6 of 16   
Video: 15:27
2957 views · 11 mins ago | 6 years ago
7 of 16   
Video: 17:39
5377 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
8 of 16   
Video: 28:11
2099 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
9 of 16   
Video: 2:38
4823 views · 12 mins ago | 5 years ago
10 of 16   
Video: 8:23
3035 views · 14 mins ago | 5 years ago
11 of 16   
Video: 9:12
4539 views · 8 hrs ago | 5 years ago
12 of 16   
Video: 23:21
3073 views · 6 hrs ago | 5 years ago
13 of 16   
Video: 26:02
5726 views · 17 mins ago | 5 years ago
14 of 16   
Video: 26:39
4776 views · 4 hrs ago | 5 years ago
15 of 16   
Video: 14:10
1250 views · 6 hrs ago | 3 years ago
16 of 16   

Latest videos  •  5,958 videos  •  0 viewed/24 hour


Torah 5   BOOKS
Psalms 1   BOOK
Old Testament 32   BOOKS
New Testament 27   BOOKS
Apocrypha 1885 14   BOOKS
Gospels/Texts 367   BOOKS
Codex 120   BOOKS
Quran 1   BOOK
Hadith 10   BOOKS


0 viewed · 24 hour
  COVID-19 Testing & Tracing Action Plan - Rockefeller Foundation
7134 views · 6 mins ago · 01 Jul
Saudi Food Wholesaler profits hit $24M on higher food demand in [...] - Arab News
4639 views · 11 hrs ago · 11 May
Saudi Arabia approves Moderna COVID Vaccine for children aged 6 years [...] - The National
5770 views · 12 mins ago · 25 Apr
Covid Crisis: Australians returning from India may be jailed for 5 [...] - The Guardian
5909 views · 3 hrs ago · 01 May
Upto 5-years jail for anyone who transmits COVID in public in Saudi [...] - Arab News
5812 views · 53 mins ago · 25 Apr
Coronavirus: Abu Dhabi police urge reports of illegal Ramadhan [...] - The National
5239 views · 12 hrs ago · 25 Apr
NEWS   1,564
About Us  |  Help/FAQ  |  Contact Us    •    Terms  |  Privacy/Disclaimer
Be Informed on Social :      Facebook Page  |    Twitter  |    Youtube is an educational website on the Prophets of God: Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad, who established the Abrahamic faiths of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. explores contemporary social themes through Scripture, Evidences, Photo, Video, Maps, Current Affairs, Debate and 'alternative' Views held by Theologians, Apologists, Scholars and Street Preachers. Take a Site Tour

In accordance with Islamic etiquette, all prophet names should be followed with 'Peace Be Upon Him (PBUH)'. This is omitted to minimise text.

DISCLAIMER: All website content is for general information and educational purposes only and available in the public domain. Whilst all information comes from sources believed to be reliable, this cannot be guaranteed. External links are provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only. They do not constitute endorsement or approval for any products, services or comments by organizations or individuals. External links text may be edited to improve internal site and keyword search options. We bear no responsibility for the accuracy, legality, or content found on any external website or its subsequent links. Unless indicated, all images and content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License distributed by Wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons, Pixabay, Pxhere, Pexels, Unsplash or Flickr. All Torah, Psalms, Old and New Testament Bible quotes are from the King James Version (KJV) Holy Bible in the public domain. All Quran quotes are from Taqi-ud-Din al-Hilali/Muhsin Khan English Quran translation. You are invited to always conduct your own research. If you spot any mistake, error or omission of information, contact us so we can correct it.