Are Gospels Based on Eyewitness Testimony - Bart Ehrman vs Richard Bauckham 2/2

Published: 21 Apr 2016  ·  Uploaded: 28 Mar 2017 Watch on Youtube.com
5138 views  ·  4 hrs ago 1:14:12

TAGS BART EHRMAN   211 RICHARD BAUCKHAM   12 GOSPEL   214
Video Description (from Youtube)
On Saturday 16th April 2016 - 02:30 pm, Bart D. Ehrman and Richard J. Bauckham join as guests with moderator Justin Brierley on radio show "Unbelievable," a weekly program aired on UK Premier Christian Radio from the London studio. They discuss "Can We Trust Eyewitness Testimony?" Bart Ehrman's new book "Jesus Before the Gospels" makes the case that the stories about Jesus would have changed and evolved before they were written down as the Gospels. Richard Bauckham, author of "Jesus and the Eyewitnesses", defends the view that the Gospels were written by those with access to eyewitness testimony of Jesus' first followers. They debate who wrote Mark, whether the Gospels came from anonymous traditions and how they received their titles.

Program discussed on Bart Ehrman's Foundation Blog: http://ehrmanblog.org/?p=11294

Christian radio show "Unbelievable" hosted by Justin Brierley: http://www.premier.org.uk/unbelievable

Bart D. Ehrman is the James A. Gray Distinguished Professor at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He came to UNC in 1988, after four years of teaching at Rutgers University. At UNC he has served as both the Director of Graduate Studies and the Chair of the Department of Religious Studies. A graduate of Wheaton College (Illinois), Professor Ehrman received both his Masters of Divinity and Ph.D. from Princeton Theological Seminary, where his 1985 doctoral dissertation was awarded magna cum laude.

Richard J. Bauckham is a New Testament scholar and professor of New Testament studies at St. Mary's College, University of St. Andrews, Scotland. "Bauckham is perhaps best known for his studies of the book of Revelation and for his commentaries on Jude and 2 Peter. He is also a thoughtful theologian who has written an introduction to the theology of Jürgen Moltmann. In his book God Crucified (1999), Bauckham displays the craft of both a careful exegete and a deft theologian as he explores the riddle of how the radically monotheistic Jews who composed the earliest church could have come to call Jesus 'Lord'." His book Jesus and the Eyewitnesses won the 2007 Book Award in Biblical Studies from Christianity Today.

Copyright © Bart D. Ehrman, Richard J. Bauckham and Justin Brierley. All Rights Reserved. Unauthorized use, re-posting and/or duplication of this media without express and written permission from Bart D. Ehrman, Richard J. Bauckham or Justin Brierley is strictly prohibited.


Shared on: 28 Mar 2017

DISCLAIMER All videos are for educational purposes only. The video is hosted on Youtube. The Video Title is derived from the original Youtube video title, video content, dialogue, speech or general content theme. The Video Title does not represent the views of any individual, speaker, organisation or business. Video Titles are further edited and optimized for SEO, keyword density, information and internal/external search. If you spot any mistake, omission or to report abuse kindly contact us.



211   Videos with 'Bart ehrman'
Video: 1:21:34
5114 views · 2 hrs ago | 9 years ago
1 of 211   
Video: 37:53
4797 views · 2 hrs ago | 9 years ago
2 of 211   
Video: 2:24:54
4443 views · 4 hrs ago | 9 years ago
3 of 211   
Video: 8:15
3231 views · 4 hrs ago | 8 years ago
4 of 211   
Video: 2:34:12
4636 views · 5 hrs ago | 8 years ago
5 of 211   
Video: 22:02
3761 views · 3 hrs ago | 8 years ago
6 of 211   
Video: 26:19
5517 views · 7 mins ago | 8 years ago
7 of 211   
Video: 5:11
9462 views · 3 hrs ago | 8 years ago
8 of 211   
Video: 1:55:04
4005 views · 4 hrs ago | 7 years ago
9 of 211   
Video: 1:29:20
3729 views · 3 hrs ago | 7 years ago
10 of 211   
Video: 21:10
3696 views · 4 hrs ago | 7 years ago
11 of 211   
Video: 1:56:52
5099 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
12 of 211   
Video: 1:02:29
5224 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
13 of 211   
Video: 1:14:12
5139 views · 0 secs ago | 7 years ago
14 of 211   
Video: 1:18:14
3715 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
15 of 211   
Video: 44:53
2383 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
16 of 211   
Video: 1:47:32
5058 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
17 of 211   
Video: 2:34:10
3383 views · 7 hrs ago | 7 years ago
18 of 211   
Video: 37:59
5090 views · 4 hrs ago | 7 years ago
19 of 211   
Video: 35:54
5298 views · 8 hrs ago | 7 years ago
20 of 211   
Video: 26:53
2328 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
21 of 211   
Video: 37:36
3943 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
22 of 211   
Video: 1:40:14
2439 views · 3 hrs ago | 7 years ago
23 of 211   
Video: 1:37:00
2613 views · 4 hrs ago | 7 years ago
24 of 211   
Video: 58:53
2569 views · 7 mins ago | 7 years ago
25 of 211   
Video: 13:10
3803 views · 5 mins ago | 7 years ago
26 of 211   
Video: 53:32
3947 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
27 of 211   
Video: 1:00:10
5018 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
28 of 211   
Video: 1:09:55
5002 views · 5 hrs ago | 7 years ago
29 of 211   
Video: 1:27:55
4423 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
30 of 211   
Video: 1:33:54
3979 views · 23 hrs ago | 7 years ago
31 of 211   
Video: 2:06:44
3298 views · 7 hrs ago | 7 years ago
32 of 211   
Video: 8:45
6445 views · 46 mins ago | 7 years ago
33 of 211   
Video: 25:52
3950 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
34 of 211   
Video: 18:39
3187 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
35 of 211   
Video: 19:23
3583 views · 4 hrs ago | 7 years ago
36 of 211   
Video: 9:53
4030 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
37 of 211   
Video: 2:01:23
2604 views · 16 hrs ago | 7 years ago
38 of 211   
Video: 3:21:27
4762 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
39 of 211   
Video: 6:40
5833 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
40 of 211   
Video: 5:53
6282 views · 2 hrs ago | 7 years ago
41 of 211   
Video: 8:25
6375 views · 1 hr ago | 7 years ago
42 of 211   
Video: 10:42
6056 views · 42 mins ago | 7 years ago
43 of 211   
Video: 53:35
2615 views · 2 hrs ago | 7 years ago
44 of 211   
Video: 51:17
2536 views · 8 hrs ago | 7 years ago
45 of 211   
Video: 48:34
2728 views · 6 hrs ago | 7 years ago
46 of 211   
Video: 3:02
4479 views · 8 mins ago | 7 years ago
47 of 211   
Video: 1:19:39
4823 views · 5 hrs ago | 7 years ago
48 of 211   
Video: 5:09
3884 views · 9 hrs ago | 7 years ago
49 of 211   
Video: 3:32
4569 views · 8 hrs ago | 7 years ago
50 of 211   
Video: 1:04:33
4495 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
51 of 211   
Video: 23:23
5723 views · 9 mins ago | 6 years ago
52 of 211   
Video: 2:33:12
2914 views · 7 hrs ago | 6 years ago
53 of 211   
Video: 1:19:09
3100 views · 11 hrs ago | 6 years ago
54 of 211   
Video: 35:06
3081 views · 11 hrs ago | 6 years ago
55 of 211   
Video: 39:33
2691 views · 11 hrs ago | 6 years ago
56 of 211   
Video: 2:11:26
2951 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
57 of 211   
Video: 13:10
5648 views · 7 hrs ago | 6 years ago
58 of 211   
Video: 17:21
3944 views · 11 hrs ago | 6 years ago
59 of 211   
Video: 3:15
4443 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
60 of 211   
Video: 2:15
4597 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
61 of 211   
Video: 0:16
7373 views · 43 mins ago | 6 years ago
62 of 211   
Video: 1:16
4902 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
63 of 211   
Video: 0:23
4416 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
64 of 211   
Video: 0:46
3433 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
65 of 211   
Video: 1:15
3438 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
66 of 211   
Video: 0:36
3207 views · 10 hrs ago | 6 years ago
67 of 211   
Video: 1:16
4718 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
68 of 211   
Video: 1:19
3677 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
69 of 211   
Video: 1:09
7138 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
70 of 211   
Video: 2:15
4117 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
71 of 211   
Video: 1:59
5500 views · 28 mins ago | 6 years ago
72 of 211   
Video: 2:27
2741 views · 10 hrs ago | 6 years ago
73 of 211   
Video: 1:51
3383 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
74 of 211   
Video: 1:23
4895 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
75 of 211   
Video: 1:33
4967 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
76 of 211   
Video: 0:53
3433 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
77 of 211   
Video: 1:04
3448 views · 7 hrs ago | 6 years ago
78 of 211   
Video: 3:33
6031 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
79 of 211   
Video: 1:54
3767 views · 10 hrs ago | 6 years ago
80 of 211   
Video: 3:46
2817 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
81 of 211   
Video: 2:00
5009 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
82 of 211   
Video: 5:01
5546 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
83 of 211   
Video: 4:23
5222 views · 10 hrs ago | 6 years ago
84 of 211   
Video: 11:10
4036 views · 23 mins ago | 6 years ago
85 of 211   
Video: 2:03
4355 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
86 of 211   
Video: 0:44
5794 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
87 of 211   
Video: 2:13
7845 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
88 of 211   
Video: 1:55
5530 views · 18 mins ago | 6 years ago
89 of 211   
Video: 4:43
3776 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
90 of 211   
Video: 1:55
4547 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
91 of 211   
Video: 0:45
4294 views · 7 hrs ago | 6 years ago
92 of 211   
Video: 2:06
5647 views · 19 mins ago | 6 years ago
93 of 211   
Video: 2:54
3121 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
94 of 211   
Video: 4:36
4215 views · 2 mins ago | 6 years ago
95 of 211   
Video: 1:04
3384 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
96 of 211   
Video: 0:30
2923 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
97 of 211   
Video: 0:09
3513 views · 10 hrs ago | 6 years ago
98 of 211   
Video: 0:35
2662 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
99 of 211   
Video: 1:12
4479 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
100 of 211   
Video: 0:50
2419 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
101 of 211   
Video: 1:39
3323 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
102 of 211   
Video: 1:48
2320 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
103 of 211   
Video: 8:31
3556 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
104 of 211   
Video: 0:57
4000 views · 10 hrs ago | 6 years ago
105 of 211   
Video: 0:26
3805 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
106 of 211   
Video: 0:13
3782 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
107 of 211   
Video: 0:52
3249 views · 10 hrs ago | 6 years ago
108 of 211   
Video: 0:51
4738 views · 44 mins ago | 6 years ago
109 of 211   
Video: 2:26
2653 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
110 of 211   
Video: 1:25
3248 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
111 of 211   
Video: 2:27
3750 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
112 of 211   
Video: 0:57
3098 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
113 of 211   
Video: 3:22
6609 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
114 of 211   
Video: 1:50
4274 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
115 of 211   
Video: 0:42
5128 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
116 of 211   
Video: 0:36
5799 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
117 of 211   
Video: 0:53
7658 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
118 of 211   
Video: 0:36
4240 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
119 of 211   
Video: 0:24
4181 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
120 of 211   
Video: 1:08
4764 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
121 of 211   
Video: 0:52
4118 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
122 of 211   
Video: 2:21
6141 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
123 of 211   
Video: 1:22
6474 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
124 of 211   
Video: 0:26
3339 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
125 of 211   
Video: 1:31
4541 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
126 of 211   
Video: 0:45
2959 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
127 of 211   
Video: 0:36
2409 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
128 of 211   
Video: 1:50
3949 views · 43 mins ago | 6 years ago
129 of 211   
Video: 0:46
4697 views · 8 mins ago | 6 years ago
130 of 211   
Video: 1:33
6276 views · 16 mins ago | 6 years ago
131 of 211   
Video: 0:36
6364 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
132 of 211   
Video: 1:36
5180 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
133 of 211   
Video: 1:57
5436 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
134 of 211   
Video: 1:44
6103 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
135 of 211   
Video: 1:38
3012 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
136 of 211   
Video: 0:36
3975 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
137 of 211   
Video: 0:46
4191 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
138 of 211   
Video: 2:06
3194 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
139 of 211   
Video: 2:29
3747 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
140 of 211   
Video: 3:15
5111 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
141 of 211   
Video: 2:30
5723 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
142 of 211   
Video: 1:58
3584 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
143 of 211   
Video: 8:02
2732 views · 7 hrs ago | 6 years ago
144 of 211   
Video: 3:44
3516 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
145 of 211   
Video: 4:53
4770 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
146 of 211   
Video: 2:08
5629 views · 47 mins ago | 6 years ago
147 of 211   
Video: 3:07
5626 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
148 of 211   
Video: 4:25
4782 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
149 of 211   
Video: 1:30
3057 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
150 of 211   
Video: 1:59
3204 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
151 of 211   
Video: 3:41
6622 views · 54 mins ago | 6 years ago
152 of 211   
Video: 1:54
6309 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
153 of 211   
Video: 4:20
4643 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
154 of 211   
Video: 3:22
4292 views · 35 mins ago | 6 years ago
155 of 211   
Video: 0:53
3990 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
156 of 211   
Video: 1:41
4402 views · 4 hrs ago | 6 years ago
157 of 211   
Video: 0:54
3210 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
158 of 211   
Video: 0:47
7814 views · 24 mins ago | 6 years ago
159 of 211   
Video: 0:38
4633 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
160 of 211   
Video: 1:50
6863 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
161 of 211   
Video: 0:53
4384 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
162 of 211   
Video: 0:46
3361 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
163 of 211   
Video: 1:34
4915 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
164 of 211   
Video: 0:31
2785 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
165 of 211   
Video: 1:02
3717 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
166 of 211   
Video: 2:17
2634 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
167 of 211   
Video: 1:01
2731 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
168 of 211   
Video: 1:03
3745 views · 7 hrs ago | 6 years ago
169 of 211   
Video: 1:09
7487 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
170 of 211   
Video: 1:36
5356 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
171 of 211   
Video: 0:36
5040 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
172 of 211   
Video: 2:09
4814 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
173 of 211   
Video: 0:41
5277 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
174 of 211   
Video: 7:35
5605 views · 19 mins ago | 6 years ago
175 of 211   
Video: 1:37
5164 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
176 of 211   
Video: 2:31
5303 views · 1 hr ago | 6 years ago
177 of 211   
Video: 2:13
4064 views · 46 mins ago | 6 years ago
178 of 211   
Video: 6:13
5765 views · 53 mins ago | 6 years ago
179 of 211   
Video: 1:58
3947 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
180 of 211   
Video: 0:31
3616 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
181 of 211   
Video: 1:12
4235 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
182 of 211   
Video: 1:02
3061 views · 9 hrs ago | 6 years ago
183 of 211   
Video: 1:13
3314 views · 3 hrs ago | 6 years ago
184 of 211   
Video: 2:48
3470 views · 1 min ago | 6 years ago
185 of 211   
Video: 0:58
7337 views · 51 mins ago | 6 years ago
186 of 211   
Video: 0:23
4063 views · 59 mins ago | 6 years ago
187 of 211   
Video: 4:55
3346 views · 5 hrs ago | 6 years ago
188 of 211   
Video: 1:51
3011 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
189 of 211   
Video: 4:31
5253 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
190 of 211   
Video: 2:56
2225 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
191 of 211   
Video: 1:11
3275 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
192 of 211   
Video: 0:38
10879 views · 39 mins ago | 6 years ago
193 of 211   
Video: 0:47
4754 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
194 of 211   
Video: 2:16
3422 views · 15 mins ago | 6 years ago
195 of 211   
Video: 1:09
4074 views · 5 mins ago | 6 years ago
196 of 211   
Video: 1:48
3160 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
197 of 211   
Video: 0:39
3496 views · 6 hrs ago | 6 years ago
198 of 211   
Video: 0:31
3129 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
199 of 211   
Video: 2:36
3955 views · 8 hrs ago | 6 years ago
200 of 211   
Video: 4:52
2889 views · 2 hrs ago | 6 years ago
201 of 211   
Video: 3:23
3344 views · 4 hrs ago | 5 years ago
202 of 211   
Video: 10:35:18
3303 views · 5 hrs ago | 5 years ago
203 of 211   
Video: 1:21
4274 views · 4 hrs ago | 4 years ago
204 of 211   
Video: 3:26
4355 views · 7 mins ago | 4 years ago
205 of 211   
Video: 3:43
2663 views · 4 hrs ago | 4 years ago
206 of 211   
Video: 1:30
4267 views · 4 hrs ago | 4 years ago
207 of 211   
Video: 3:46
3912 views · 4 hrs ago | 4 years ago
208 of 211   
Video: 3:44
1953 views · 3 hrs ago | 4 years ago
209 of 211   
Video: 1:29:01
3338 views · 4 hrs ago | 4 years ago
210 of 211   
Video: 10:19
2262 views · 2 hrs ago | 2 years ago
211 of 211   


Latest videos  •  5,958 videos  •  0 viewed/24 hour

ARTICLES

0 viewed · 24 hour
Are you a Muslim?
3 mins | Online Test
Timeline of Muhammad
6772 views · 3 mins ago
10 Commandments - Christian vs Muslim
12531 views · 5 mins ago
The Prophets Prayer
9690 views · 7 mins ago
COVID: Lockdowns & Contact Tracing in 78 Countries
7421 views · 8 mins ago
Constantine, Nicaea and History
8576 views · 10 mins ago
ARTICLES   154

SCRIPTURE

Torah 5   BOOKS
Psalms 1   BOOK
Old Testament 32   BOOKS
New Testament 27   BOOKS
Apocrypha 1885 14   BOOKS
Gospels/Texts 367   BOOKS
Codex 120   BOOKS
Quran 1   BOOK
Hadith 10   BOOKS
SCRIPTURES   580

NEWS

0 viewed · 24 hour
  COVID-19 Testing & Tracing Action Plan - Rockefeller Foundation
6962 views · 14 hrs ago · 01 Jul
Saudi Food Wholesaler profits hit $24M on higher food demand in [...] - Arab News
4379 views · 8 hrs ago · 11 May
Saudi Arabia approves Moderna COVID Vaccine for children aged 6 years [...] - The National
5553 views · 2 hrs ago · 25 Apr
Covid Crisis: Australians returning from India may be jailed for 5 [...] - The Guardian
5684 views · 1 hr ago · 01 May
Upto 5-years jail for anyone who transmits COVID in public in Saudi [...] - Arab News
5584 views · 8 hrs ago · 25 Apr
Coronavirus: Abu Dhabi police urge reports of illegal Ramadhan [...] - The National
5057 views · 1 hr ago · 25 Apr
NEWS   1,564
About Us  |  Help/FAQ  |  Contact Us    •    Terms  |  Privacy/Disclaimer
Be Informed on Social :      Facebook Page  |    Twitter  |    Youtube
MuslimProphets.com is an educational website on the Prophets of God: Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad, who established the Abrahamic faiths of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. MuslimProphets.com explores contemporary social themes through Scripture, Evidences, Photo, Video, Maps, Current Affairs, Debate and 'alternative' Views held by Theologians, Apologists, Scholars and Street Preachers. Take a Site Tour

In accordance with Islamic etiquette, all prophet names should be followed with 'Peace Be Upon Him (PBUH)'. This is omitted to minimise text.

DISCLAIMER: All website content is for general information and educational purposes only and available in the public domain. Whilst all information comes from sources believed to be reliable, this cannot be guaranteed. External links are provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only. They do not constitute endorsement or approval for any products, services or comments by organizations or individuals. External links text may be edited to improve internal site and keyword search options. We bear no responsibility for the accuracy, legality, or content found on any external website or its subsequent links. Unless indicated, all images and content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License distributed by Wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons, Pixabay, Pxhere, Pexels, Unsplash or Flickr. All Torah, Psalms, Old and New Testament Bible quotes are from the King James Version (KJV) Holy Bible in the public domain. All Quran quotes are from Taqi-ud-Din al-Hilali/Muhsin Khan English Quran translation. You are invited to always conduct your own research. If you spot any mistake, error or omission of information, contact us so we can correct it.
Clustrmaps